Skip to main content

Guerlain Derby ( Current Bee Bottle and Vintage formula)

Image
By
First off, allow me to thank a very generous basenoter who goes by the name of Oaksbluff for sending me samples of not only the current formula, but the vintage as well. Dan was awesome enough to offer when he read a thread I initiated on the price point of this highly esteemed masculine. My gratitude to Dan.....especially since this isn't the first time he sent me some gems.....

I opted to sample the current formula from the Bee Bottle first. Aside from it being very smooth and ( of course) very good, the first thing that sprang to my mind is how similar it is to Gucci PH circa 1976. Now, I have always loved Gucci PH original and still wear that terrific leather chypre. As a matter of fact, I have another 125ml bottle enroute from my good friend Henry ( xmen) because it is superb. I am amazed enough to consider them first cousins.

It didn't take me long to undergo side by side comparisons of current Derby and Gucci, then both renditions of Derby versus Gucci. This was never meant to be a contest, only to compare since my nose detects a direct relation of all three. The vintage Derby is closer to Gucci with its inherent overall heaviness. This is very common in scents constructed from the mid 1970's to the very early 1990's. Vintage Derby has an all star floral heart that's comparable to Gucci, but definitely superior.

With that said, current Derby begins with a citric woody accord that broadcasts the transitions will have nary a ripple. You can tell immediately that the shifting of accords will be seamless. I believe that is part of the magic that is Derby. The current version possesses a more definable passing of one accord to the next. I think this is one of the few advantages of scents that are lighter in nature. I could not tell when it happened....but just that it did. The vintage, being heavier in ingredients, moves slower due to denseness and maintains a common aura from start to finish. It's not linear as much as it is like a glacier carving a landscape. Being the heartnote monster that it is, to me the mids dominate here and it causes me to lose sight of the forest due to the trees.

Both Derby renditions are pretty terrific. My wife loves the current formula whereas I lean toward the heavier vintage. Owning either one is a win-win situation if you enjoy leather chypres. Even though the vintage Derby is more to my liking, its similarities to Gucci ( which I already have enough of) may make it a bit redundant in spite of it being superior to Gucci. To me, it is Gucci ( 1976) with a better floral array. The vintage Derby and Gucci share these same notes :

Artemesia, Bergamot Oil, Lemon, Jasmin, Pepper, Pimento, Leather, Moss, Patchouli & Sandal.

Quite a few of the other notes are replaced by others of the same ilk. They both have a very similar idea on how to get to the same destination. Vintage Derby drives first class while Gucci is a passenger in the upper middle class section. The rest is splitting hairs...............

Suffice it to say that current or vintage Derby is a worthy addition to the drobe. The current is friskier than the vintage, a tad lighter in construction, but a notable leather chypre all the same. I'm not one to pidgeonhole fragrances without cause and I certainly am not trying to do it now. To me, current Derby may be more suitable or wearable for the younger chypre crowd as it is less era-identifiable as it's older brother. Both should be sampled just for the hell of it.......and just because they rock. BIG THUMBS UP from Aromi for either Derby rendition.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Black Suede by Avon

By
Nutmeg, Clove, Amber, Musk, Moss, Wood Notes. Yes.........I am reviewing one of the Rodney Dangerfield's of fragrance. Black Suede has been gracing medicine cabinets, for better or worse, since 1980 my friends. If you're expecting me to inform you ( like others may have already ) that Black Suede is a nasty scrubber, you will be disappointed. On the other hand, if you're expecting a glowing review claiming it's a diamond in the rough, you won't hear that from me either. I will say though that Black Suede doesn't deserve the hate it's received and most of that is due to snobbery aimed at Avon products in general. I kid you not when I state that a close relative to this fragrance is Cacharel Pour L'Homme. The array of spice in both ensure comparison, but the "smoother" of the two is Black Suede due to its implementation of Amber. While wearing Black Suede, one can detect a hint of "drugstore". That quality doesn't manife...
1 comment
Read more

Chanel copying Guerlain. Why?

By
                      Last month, I had the pleasure of trying Comète by Chanel, the latest addition to their prestigious Les Exclusifs line. This fragrance follows the release of Le Lion in 2020, another standout in the same collection. Like Le Lion , Comète is a beautiful perfume that captures the essence of Chanel’s refined elegance. However, both fragrances bear a striking resemblance to classic creations by Guerlain, leading me to ponder the direction Chanel is taking. Chanel has a great fragrance history. Not as hallowed and old as Guerlain but for past three decades it has far outshone Guerlain. In my view, no other perfume house has come close to Chanel’s excellence in this century. This makes their recent approach of echoing Guerlain classics somewhat perplexing. Have they run out of fresh ideas? Is Roger Dove at the helm of their fragrance division, or have they perhaps...
Post a Comment
Read more

Teatro Alla Scala - Krizia

By
I tried Comete by Chanel today and wanted to write about how Chanel is going by the way of Roger Dove - copying old masterpieces. I did not know where to post that and then I realized I have been neglecting this blog. When I logged in I saw an unfinished post I wrote a year ago about Teatro Alla Scala by Krizia. Teatro is the best full bodied floral - better than any Chanel or Patou. Even better than Gucci L'Arte.  A brief background: Teatro Alla Scala is an Opera theatre in Milan. The bottle's design is an homage to the theatre and the perfume an homage to its sophisticated patrons. I wanted to write a symphony for it. Maybe some day. For now here are few notes I wrote comparing EDT vs EDP.  And if you don't have Teatro, your wardrobe is incomplete Rose, Jasmine, Tuberose. Jammy berries (more in EDP) . Honey note listed is probably the jammy part Vetiver & moss - more in EDT Rose and carnation is more than jasmine and that is what separates it from other florals like J...
Post a Comment
Read more